Mr Khatami’s Riddles!

God bless Mr Khatami! Once again he has proposed[1] riddles to be resolved by the Iranian people. He said, “There is a plan which must be disturbed”. But, the question is what plan, by whom? Who is planning to do what? He immediately added “in whatever way possible we have to disrupt this game”. Once again, what game Mr Khatami? Who are the players and what are their aims and objectives? For the people at large who are being crashed under unprecedented economic hardship, you propose a riddle to be resolved! Unspecified “plan” and “game would not help any one. How can any one disturb a plan, if it is to remain a “secret”! Why do you not face these issues up front and tell the people in no uncertain term what do you think is going on and what you think they should or should not do. Having not resolved the first riddle we come to another, “while submissive, we would mirthfully participate in the elections”. I must admit, I am confused here. I am really confused. If you participate mirthfully, then, why submissive and if you are submissive, how can you be mirthful? If as it has been reported and is confirmed in this speech by Khatami himself, in most of the constituencies the reformist groups have no candidate, how can you be mirthful? He continued, “If Majlis- Iranian Parliament- occupies its true place in the country” and”support the popular participation in these elections, we can prevent swindle!” First and foremost, if elections are not fair and free, how can Majlis occupies its real place in the pyramid of power in the country? And he knows well that elections are not fair and are not planned to be free, given the compulsory process of seeking “consent” from more than one non-elected powerful bodies for the candidates. Furthermore, in a political structure under which one person enjoys absolute power over all the elected bodies, as Velayat-e faghih – the Guardian of the State- does in the Islamic Republic of Iran, what is the real place for a parliament anyway! Has he forgotten the record of the sixth Majlis, which has become totally toothless after a few decrees issued by the faghih! In addition to the Faghih, there is of course the Guardian Council- Shoura-ye negah-ban- and all bills passed through parliament should be approved by the Council to become law and if this un-elected body does not like them, they would simply refuse approval without having to be accountable to anyone. Again the record of sixth majlis is quite clear on this issue too. It seems that Mr Khatami has just woken up from a deep sleep as he says we have to “prevent the return of despotism”! Really! God bless you Sir! Did despotism go anywhere that now, you are afraid that it may return? Are you saying that you are not aware of what are going on in front of your own eyes in the country? The way that university students are being treated, the way that workers are being suppressed. What about women activists! Do you not know all these or do you prefer to ignore them? However, after a little more waffle, Mr Khatami proposes another riddle, to achieve what he has suggested, “It is important to point out that critical press and parties are essential”. Does he not know that neither would be tolerated by the authorities in Iran? It seems that Mr Khatami does not pay attention to what his political colleagues are saying in the country which is a clear indication of what might happen in the near future. However, the Speaker of the House who is not qualified to issue fatwa, has issued one pointing out that “weakening of the government from whatever source, is forbidden and haram”. Anyone who is familiar with Iranian political culture knows the meaning of this “fatwa”, i.e. less tolerance and more arrests to follow. What is worrying is the Speaker, Mr Haddad Adel, is not one of the hard-liners in the authority! As said earlier, Khatami while talking about “mirthful participation” in these elections, also confirmed that “in most constituencies, the reformists cannot compete with others in the elections” as their candidates failed to be approved. Given this situation, how then they can mirthfully participate in an exercise from which they have been barred? What is really disturbing, however, is this that Mr Khatami seems to be incapable of learning from his mistakes. For eight long years, during his two terms presidency, using a very similar language, Mr Khatami offered riddles to the people of Iran, and now, he continues with the same tradition. He encourages the people to be “actively involved” in these elections, and this is despite the fact that he knows full well that the scope for active participation is not available. He has even turned to those candidates who were not approved and, consequently, could not compete in these elections and asked them to be “actively involved and encourage the voters to participate in full”. What I believe it boils down to once again, is Mr Khatami’s attempt to abuse people’s confidence in him to support the main current in the Islamic Republic of Iran which in fact, tolerates him for this very reason. As a kind of carrot that could prepare the situation for the use of the stick. What Mr Khatami does not seem to understand is when the main current with the help of him and other “reformists” like him succeeded in destroying what is left of civil society in Iran by crashing all the civil opposition, then, it would be his turn. Why I say this is linked with the current deep rooted economic crisis for which Mr Ahmadinejad’s government had effectively nothing to offer except populist slogans about nuclear energy. These slogans may have been attractive two years ago, but not any more. In support of this view point, let us consider what Kiyan ersi[2], one of the few remaining reformist candidate said when he was asked which political groups you think would have more support in the elections, the reformists or the fundamentalists? To which he replied, “We are reaching a point that this type of classification is becoming irrelevant. Hunger, economic pressure, problems with housing, problems related to income, eduction, marriage, and jobs would not recognise reformism from fundamentalism”.
In such a situation, active and mirthful participation in these elections is nothing but an act of working towards guaranteeing political legitimacy to those who have brought Iran to its knees. For God’s sake Mr Khatami, please try to be honest with the people of Iran and stop offering these riddles. To overcome these difficult conditions, they need leadership, not riddles.
[1] the speech could be read here, http://www.aftabnews.ir/vdcgqz9akz9xu.html
[2] for further details see, http://tabnak.ir/pages/?cid=7518